If you lost a property to a tax sale and assumed the leftover money was gone for good, it might be time to look again — especially if it’s been a few years. A Supreme Court case most people have never heard of has been quietly pushing states to rewrite their rules, and the list of states doing it keeps growing.
Here’s the short version. In May 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on a case called Tyler v. Hennepin County. A county in Minnesota had sold a woman’s home to cover a tax debt of about $15,000 — then kept the full sale price, which was worth far more than what she owed. The Court said that’s not allowed. If a tax sale brings in more than the debt, the leftover equity still belongs to the former owner. Keeping it isn’t just unfair, the Court said — it’s an unconstitutional taking of property.
That ruling didn’t automatically fix every state’s laws, but it lit a fire under a lot of state legislatures. Since 2023, we’ve tracked at least fourteen states that have passed their own reforms to make sure former owners actually get a real, workable path to their surplus funds: Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Illinois, Louisiana, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nebraska, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, and South Dakota.
A couple of these are worth calling out by name. Illinois is the newest — Governor Pritzker signed HB4537 in July of this year, creating what the law calls a “Surplus Equity Fund.” What makes it interesting is that it’s retroactive: it reaches back to cover tax deeds recorded since July 2024. If that’s you, you may have a claim today that simply didn’t exist a year ago. New York reformed its own rules back in 2024 under RPTL Article 11, giving former residential owners a three-year window to claim unclaimed surplus after a sale is confirmed — a real improvement over having no clear process at all.
Every one of these states wrote its own version of the fix, so the fee rules, deadlines, and paperwork aren’t identical from state to state. What they share is the same starting point: a former owner is legally owed that money, and more states are expected to keep joining this list as legislatures catch up to what the Court decided.
That’s really the point of this piece, and why we’re going to keep updating it. If your state passed a law like this recently, or if you simply never checked before because you figured the door had closed, the door may be open now in a way it wasn’t last year. It costs you nothing to find out.
We watch this list so you don’t have to. If you lost a property to a tax sale anywhere in the country, reach out and we’ll tell you — at no cost — whether a reform like this applies to you and whether there’s money waiting on your name.
Adam Austin is a Recovery Specialist with Steward Fund Recovery, based in Jacksonville, Florida.
